What happens between the ages of five and eleven, and how we can keep the joy alive

Joanne Robinson, Founding Partner, The Little Art School Charity

Five-year-olds love being handed paper and paint. By eleven, very few children will draw joyfully. Something happens in between. Its the reason so many children stop drawing and it changes how a child sees themselves. 

At the very beginning of the Little Art School story, I travelled round more than twenty primary schools. I spoke to hundreds of children. I took a big painting with me, and a belief I badly wanted to share; anyone can learn to draw and paint. But these are skills, and skills have to be taught, practised and developed. In every class I asked the same two questions:  “do you like drawing and painting?” and “do you think you are good at drawing and painting?” In Primary 1 (average age about 5 years) every single hand went up with a resounding YES to both questions. Then I worked my way up through the year groups. The older the children were, the fewer hands went up. By Primary 7, only a handful said they liked drawing and painting, and barely any would say they were good at it.

That contrast has stayed with me ever since. I wanted to know what happens to children to make them lose both their love of art and their belief in their ability to make art. Because art matters. It can lift a child’s mental health and build a confidence they carry into adulthood. This post outlines what I found out, and what we at the Little Art School think we can do about it.

The cat that doesn’t look like a cat

Picture a five-year-old with a pot of red paint and a big sheet of paper. There are splashes everywhere. A few swirls, a handprint, a drip running down the page. She holds it up, beaming. It’s a dragon, she tells you. Or a birthday cake. Or her granny. It is wonderful, and she knows it is wonderful.

Now picture the same girl at eight or nine. She wants to draw her cat. She knows exactly what her cat looks like, because she has stroked it every day for years. But the thing on the page has legs that bend the wrong way, a head more like a potato, and ears that could belong to a rabbit. She looks at it for a long moment. It doesn’t look like a cat.

A kind adult leans over and says, “That’s lovely. It’s your interpretation.” She isn’t fooled. She knows it doesn’t look like a cat. And she has just learned something that may stay with her for life: that she is not an artist. She probably won’t try very hard to draw a cat again.

This is one of the most common moments in childhood, and one of the most overlooked. Did it happen to you?

It happened to me. I remember my own moment so clearly, and it was over forty-five years ago. I was sitting in my classroom, happily drawing. Then I looked at the work of the boy next to me. His drawing was brilliant. Mine was basic. On his drawing the head looked like a real head. Mine didn’t. He could draw. I couldn’t. And just like that, something that had brought me such joy was ruined.

I was in my thirties when I realised that drawing and painting are taught skills. I felt robbed of decades of joy. I also became determined, and honestly a bit evangelical, about telling everyone what I had worked out.


You can learn to draw. We have been sold a myth.


You can learn to draw
why children stop drawing

To understand where that myth came from, we need to go back more than a hundred years.

When drawing was a lesson like any other

In Victorian Britain, drawing was taught in schools in much the same way as reading and arithmetic. From the 1850s, a national system run from South Kensington set out a graded course. Children began with simple lines and shapes, then moved on to perspective and shading, and eventually to drawing real objects. The government wanted skilled designers for British industry, and it believed any child could be taught to draw.

It was far from perfect. A great deal of it was dull copying, and plenty of people said so at the time. But it rested on an idea we have since lost. Drawing is a skill. It can be broken into steps. It can be practised. And almost anyone can get better at it.

The art schools of the day thought the same. Students spent years learning to draw the figure, understand anatomy and handle paint. Nobody expected them to arrive already able to do it. That was what the training was for.

The discovery of “child art”

Around 1900, the thinking changed. Instead of seeing children as small adults who needed training, people began to see them as naturally creative, with a purity that grown-ups had lost. Artists such as Picasso and Klee admired children’s drawings for a boldness that academic training seemed to squash.

In Vienna, a teacher called Franz Cižek opened a class for children and made it his mission to protect their art from adult interference. He believed the worst thing a teacher could do was show them how. In England, Marion Richardson had children close their eyes and paint the “mind pictures” they saw. The writer Herbert Read then gave the movement a philosophy, arguing in 1943 that the teacher’s job was to draw out what was already inside the child.

The most influential of all was Viktor Lowenfeld. His 1947 book Creative and Mental Growth trained art teachers for decades. It told them not to give children models to copy and not to impose adult ideas of what a picture should look like. Doing so, he warned, would damage a child’s confidence.

These were thoughtful people with good intentions. They had seen how joyless the old system could be and they wanted children to love art. But something important changed along the way. Teaching was recast as interference. Copying, which is how artists had learned for centuries, became almost forbidden. The teacher’s role shifted from passing on a skill to standing back and protecting a gift.

Why children stop drawing at eight or nine

Here is the problem. “Just play” suits a five-year-old perfectly. Young children don’t mind whether their dragon looks like a dragon. The joy is in the colour, the mess and the story they tell about it. Praise is easy to give and easy to believe.

But children change. Somewhere around eight or nine they start wanting their pictures to look like the real thing. Lowenfeld noticed this himself and called it “dawning realism”. Children become critical of their own work. They compare it with the world, and with the drawing of the child sitting next to them.

This is exactly the moment they most need to be shown how. How to look at a cat and see the shapes it is made of. Where the ears really sit. How the back legs fold. Instead, many are told there is no right or wrong, and that whatever they have done is their own interpretation. Telling a child their cat is “their interpretation” does not protect their confidence. They can see it doesn’t look like a cat. What they hear is that nobody is going to help them fix it.

Praise that doesn’t match what a child can see with their own eyes does not build self-esteem. It quietly teaches them that adults won’t tell them the truth, and that the gap between what they want and what they can do is simply how things are. Most children draw the obvious conclusion. Some people can draw. They can’t.

This pattern is well documented. When Ofsted looked at art teaching in English schools, it found that children got off to a confident start in the early years and then made slow progress in drawing through primary school. Weaknesses in the teaching of drawing, which inspectors called a fundamental skill, had not been put right. Fewer than a quarter of the teachers surveyed had had any specialist art training in the previous year. Teachers are not to blame here. Most have never been taught how to teach it.

The myth of the “natural”

Once you stop teaching a skill, you need another way to explain why some people are good at it. The answer our culture reached for was talent. If all children are natural artists and adults must not teach, then anyone who can draw well must have been born with a gift.
Drawing stopped looking like something you learn and started looking like something you either have or you don’t. Almost a kind of magic, handed out to the lucky few.
The research doesn’t support that. Studies of children’s drawings show they learn a great deal by borrowing from the pictures around them, from comics, books and each other. Psychologists who study skill have shown again and again that people improve at music and sport through focused practice, and drawing is no different. Research with art students has found that those who practise more draw better, and that training changes how people see.
Some children do show unusual ability early on. Nobody denies that. But the idea that drawing is a gift which teaching can only spoil simply isn’t true.
The art colleges went the same way, for their own reasons. Over the second half of the twentieth century, many moved away from teaching technique towards experiment, and then towards ideas and concepts. One study of nearly 300 British art students found that some of them could not draw well and wished they could. They had reached art school without ever being taught the skills that, a century earlier, were the whole point of going. If art colleges no longer teach drawing, it is hard to argue that a primary school should.

Nobody hands a child a violin and says “just play”

Think about how we teach music. No one hands a child a violin and walks away. We find a teacher. The child learns how to hold the bow, how to find a note, how to play a scale. Simple tunes first, harder ones later. Practice, and plenty of squeaky moments along the way.
Nobody calls that stifling. When a child plays their first real tune, they are proud because they know they earned it. They can hear the difference between where they started and where they are now. That is where real confidence comes from.
Drawing and painting work in exactly the same way. When a child is shown, step by step, how to draw that cat, and it finally looks like a cat, the pride on their face is unmistakable. It isn’t the pride of being told something is lovely. It is the pride of knowing they did it themselves.
Structure and freedom belong together
None of this means going back to Victorian copybooks. Play still matters, and a five-year-old with a pot of paint should be left to enjoy every minute of it.
Structure and creativity are not opposites. A child who knows how to mix the exact green they want is free to paint the garden they imagine. A child who knows how to show distance can create whole worlds.


Skill doesn’t replace imagination. It gives imagination somewhere to go.


This belief is at the heart of everything we do at The Little Art School. In our classes, and in the schools we visit through our free Little Art Stars programme, children learn to draw and paint one clear step at a time. Each lesson builds on the last. Our studios are still noisy and messy and full of laughter, but the children know they are getting better, because they can see it.

We watch the same thing happen again and again. Children who were sure they couldn’t draw discover that they can. As one girl told us at the end of a term, “I learnt that if you can’t do something straight away, you just keep trying.”

That is what we want for every child. Not to be told their cat is lovely when they can see that it isn’t. But to be shown how to draw a cat that really does look like a cat, and to carry that feeling of “I can do this” into everything else they try.

So if I could go back into those school halls and ask my two questions again, I would want every hand in Primary 7 to go up too. That is the whole point of what we do.


Joanne Robinson is Founding Partner of The Little Art School Charity. She studied history at Oxford University and holds a Masters with Distinction in Museum and Gallery Studies from Winchester School of Art, University of Southampton, where she looked at how children learn in galleries and museums. She has spent the years since teaching drawing and painting to children and adults, and arguing that both are skills anyone can be taught.


The Little Art School Charity is a registered Scottish charity (SC045848), with studios in Ayr and Kilmarnock. We teach structured, progressive drawing and painting to children and adults, and the profits from our courses pay for our charitable work. That includes free art sessions for people living with dementia, and our Little Art Stars programme, which takes free lessons into Ayrshire schools where children would not otherwise get the chance to learn art. Last year that meant around 2,400 free sessions for children across five partner schools.

Find out more about our Childrens Classes and what our Community Projects involve

And if you are one of the many adults who gave up art as a child because you believed the myth, our online course for adults was made for you. It begins at the very beginning and takes you one clear step at a time. It is never too late to be taught. I should know!